I thought the hotel was very well maintained for how old it is. It was also decorated cute with a nod to the 1800's but without going over-board or being fussy.
We were pretty comfortable except that we were on the 3rd floor and there are no elevators. Being older and not in the best shape, it was a little challenging for us, especially when we hauled our 50 lb suitcase up the first night. If it hadn't been for the help of Forest, the very nice owner of the tasty bbq restaurant in the same building, I'm not sure if we would have made it!
The beds were a little hard, but not too bad, and we lost water pressure in the shower for a couple of minutes a few times, but it stayed hot throughout the showers so we were happy. The bonus was the fluffy towels! We've traveled a lot and I think those towels are in the top 2%!
We also had very good wifi service and were able to stream Netflix without any problem.
My only complaint would be that when I booked the room, I thought I booked in the 2-story building (there are 2 separate buildings) so I was ok with no elevator. So make sure you request a lower floor if stairs are a challenge for you.
And make sure you stop in to the Fireside BBQ and say "Hi!" to Forest!