I would have given it a "5", but for one glaring detail; there is NO BREAKFAST (despite being advertised as such). They put out coffee and orange juice, along with one edible item (a sort of muffin sized piece of cinnamon bread/roll... which since one of us is diabetic and the other can't do wheat, made it inedible). So we had to drop about $80 on three breakfast meals elsewhere. No explanation nor solution offered by staff. Also (unrelated) the tiny elevator has to be manually called by staff for the couple times we had to use it when moving luggage. And FYI, no on-site parking... street parking only (though that was not an issue)
Otherwise....a beautiful property convenient to lots of restaurants (walking to or driving to, on Magazine Street) and walking around the garden district. Staff is very nice. Room was beautiful (though the bathroom...tub only...was what you might expect from a 19th century conversion. I would certainly recommend to anyone, especially if you are looking for a unique (non corporate) environment. Just aggravated (still) about being misled about the breakfast.