My wife and I booked their newer cottage before the Summer Season officially started. Lower rate, but also most of Tobermory is shut down.
Due to being out of season, it was actually kind of difficult to check in. The motel side of this business is closed, but cottages are open. We were not given any direction prior to arriving - and the office is closed. Called the property to no answer, we honestly started to get worried. My wife found a contact on facebook and was finally able to get ahold of someone who helped direct us to our cottage. Could've easily been a disaster.
The cottage is beautiful. However, the water that came out of any faucet at any given time was orange/brown. Not great.
Wifi stopped working, someone ended up coming out to restart the router behind a locked closet door in the house, polite and happy to help us.
Check out time also unclear. Everywhere on the property says check out is 10am, but Expedia checkout says 11am. Should clarify.
Otherwise, likely a very accommodating and awesome place to stay during the summer months. Generally, would recommend (figure out the water situation though...)