We had a large group (8 families, including kids 3-10 years old). As our families have grown, it is increasingly hard to find a place where everyone has their own bed. This fit the bill! There was also plenty of space in the common areas -- 30+ seats for indoor and outdoor dining, two separate living rooms, a huge fire pit, and plenty of dishes to feed a crowd. Although I wouldn't say it was luxurious, everything was comfortable, clean, and exactly as pictured in the listing.
The host, Ted, was friendly and helpful. He greeted us in person to show us around, provided great advice on local spots, and left a nice welcome basket. When we had an issue with the house, he responded within an hour and came out to check on things.
The only reason I would not give 5 stars is that one of the basements smelled horrible -- very musty. We also had issues with water leaking in two different spots when people showered. The first time I thought maybe we had let too much water escape the shower curtain, but the second time we clearly didn't let any water get onto the floor. One of the leaks was into the musty basement, so I suspect it may have been happening for a while unnoticed. Ted was responsive, but it was a big enough plumbing problem that he couldn't resolve it during our stay.
It was still a generally positive experience and we'd rent again if the leaks/smell are addressed. Kitchen was missing coffee filters, aluminum foil, & a whisk. Future renters may way want to BYO